Meghan is NOT writing Charles' letters, he just likes using 15th Century English: Prince's eccentric spellings are explained after Royal watchers object to 'Americanisms' in letter to Macron after Notre Dame fire
- The Prince of Wales has come under fire online over his 'American' spelling
- Wrote a heartfelt letter to the French president following the Notre Dame fire
- Letter was posted to the Clarence House Instagram account but was slammed
- Fans said 'Americanised' spellings including 'realize' should be 'British English'
- The use of 'ize' is actually traditional British spelling dating back to 15th century
The Prince of Wales has come under fire for using 'American' spellings in a heartfelt letter, written to the French president following the Notre Dame fire.
On Tuesday, a letter of sympathy written by Prince Charles, 70, to Emmanuel Macron, 41, in the wake of the cathedral inferno, was shared to the Clarence House Instagram account.
Despite the touching message, many of the royal's 714,000 followers were distracted by the 'Americanised' spellings - a day after fans claimed Meghan is running the SussexRoyal Instagram account, due to US words and phrases in the captions.
Arguing that the future King should stick to British English, fans pointed out that 'agonizing, realize and civilizaton' were used in the letter, as opposed to 'agonising, realise and civilisaton'.
Others suggested that his spellings could have been autocorrected, with most word processing programmes using American English as their default setting for spellchecking.
Clarence House declined to comment, but it's believed that Charles prefers to use the 'correct' 15th century versions of English, when words were spelled with an 'ize' instead of 'ise'.
Examples of previous letters written by the royal, show that he has always used spellings such as 'recognize' and 'realize'.
The Prince of Wales, seen with Camilla, has come under fire online over his 'American' spelling in a heartfelt letter written to the French president following the Notre Dame fire - with many fans not realising the use of 'ize' dates back to traditional British English spelling
David Adger, Professor of Linguistics at Queen Mary University of London, confirmed to Femail that Prince Charles' spelling is techincally correct, if unusual in 2019.
He said: 'The -ize spelling is a pretty accurate representation of the Ancient Greek suffix from which it derives, which was roughly pronounced -idzo.
'It's still used by, for example, Oxford University Press, instead of the more standard -ise.
'However, for words that don't come from that Ancient Greek affix, like analyse, for example, Oxford University Press sticks with the -se spelling, while American English has generalised even those words.'
The full letter reads: 'My wife and I were utterly heartbroken to learn of the terrible fire at Notre-Dame cathedral this evening and wanted to let you know immediately how much we were thinking of yourself and the French people at this most agonizing of times, and of the emergency services who are so bravely tackling the blaze.
'I realize only too well what a truly special significance the Cathedral holds at the heart of your nation; but also for us all outside France it represents one of the greatest architectural achievements of Western Civilization.
'It is a treasure for all mankind, as such, to witness its destruction in its most dreadful conflagration is a terrible tragedy, the unbearable pain of which we all share.
'Cher Monsieur le President, our hearts go out to you and the people of France more than you will ever know, especially in view of our experience with the devastating fire at Windsor Castle twenty-seven years ago.
'We send you our most profound sympathy, however inadequate that may be.'
Previous letters written by Prince Charles show he has always used the traditional 'ize' spelling.
However, one commenter who was unhappy with the spelling in the letter, said: 'Wait what? A British uses 'realize' not realise? Are you an American or the future King?'.
On Tuesday a letter of sympathy written by Prince Charles, 70, to Emmanuel Macron, 41, in the wake of the cathedral's fire on Monday, was shared to the Clarence House Instagram account
However, despite the touching message, many of the royal's 714,000 followers took to the post to slam the 'Americanised' spellings
Another added: 'Agonising with a z - that will not do', while one wrote: 'Please ask your secretary not to write Americanised English!'.
Elsewhere one follower argued: 'What hope is there for our schoolchildren, when even HRH starts spelling 'realise' with a 'z'?'.
'Realise! Not realize. Not criticising the sentiment of the letter though, just to be clear,' another wrote.
Why are we eschewing the Queen's English for Americanisms?' another questioned.
Arguing the royal family should set an example, another said: '*Realise* not realise (we are not American) ... HRH is supposed to be a stickler for grammar and accurate spelling!'.
One fan even joked that Charles was dictating the letter, and his American daughter-in-law Meghan had typed it up.
Users quickly slammed the post, with one follower writing: 'Wait what? A British uses 'realize' not realise? Are you an American or the future King?'
However many others defended the letter, arguing that the spelling was irrelevant in light of the tragedy.
'Beautifully stated but I am so sorry to see the amount of criticism here. Have a heart, people!' one said.
Another argued the post was aimed at an international audience, adding: 'Let's not be petty and argue about regional differences. We all speak English.'
Meanwhile one said: 'The world has just lost an iconic historic building in tragic circumstances which was originally erected in 1161 and took centuries to complete. It had over a million visitors annually, it housed priceless treasures and all you can complain about is a spell checker's spelling?'.
However many others defended the letter, arguing that the spelling was irrelevant in light of the tragedy
Speaking to FEMAIL, royal etiquette expert William Hanson said: 'It is a shame that Clarence House inadvertently used the American English version of 'realise'.
'All communication aimed at the British public should be in British English. One of the softer roles the monarchy has to play is maintaining traditional standards.
'The British monarchy should uphold correct British English - or, as it used to just be called, English. But I do wonder whether Clarence House chose to use the more internationally recognised spelling on purpose as the message was meant for a global audience? Perhaps we should give them the benefit of the doubt.'
This comes after fans took to the SussexRoyal Instagram account on Tuesday, claiming the Americanised spelling on its most recent post meant that California-born Meghan was writing the captions herself.
Meghan, 37, and Harry, 34, recently thanked fans for donating to their chosen charities in honour of Baby Sussex, and one post about Baby2Baby contains references to 'cribs' and 'diapers'.
Several posts use the US spelling 'organization', rather than 'organisation' and 'programs' rather than 'programmes'.
And fans were also quick to spot 'Americanised' spellings, as well as dollar signs and American English in the captions, and claimed this pointed to a US native writing them.
Eagle-eyed fans took to the SussexRoyal Instagram account on Tuesday, claiming the Americanised spelling on its most recent post meant that California-born Meghan was writing the captions herself
Most watched News videos
- Rishi Sunak tries to get Prince William's attention at D-Day event
- Tourist killed by train when she stood near track for selfie
- Biden commemorates 80th anniversary of D-Day in Normandy
- 'We are inspired': War veteran shares sweet moment with Zelensky
- Nigel from Hertford, 74, is not impressed with politicians
- British D-day veterans dance during commemoration
- BBC live records person swearing 'French a******s' on D-Day coverage
- Nigel Farage and Penny Mordaunt blast Rishi over D-day fiasco
- 'That was a mistake': Rishi apologises for leaving D-Day event early
- Farage slams 'disconnected Rishi Sunak' for leaving D-Day early
- CCTV captures last sighting of missing Dr Michael Mosley
- Touching moment D-day veteran kisses Zelensky's hand